The Birth of Product Management: Neil H. McElroy’s Visionary Legacy

Nikhil Chakravarthi
2 min readNov 7, 2023
The Beginning of the Brand Men

As someone into Product Management, I am entrenched in the intricacies of market research, development strategies, and lifecycle management, I often reflect on the origins of our discipline. It was in 1931, amid the daily grind at Procter & Gamble (P&G), that a revolutionary concept was born through a simple internal memo penned by Neil H. McElroy. This wasn’t just any memo — it was the Rosetta Stone for Product Management.

McElroy identified a critical gap in the way products were being marketed and managed. He posited that instead of the prevailing sales-focused approach, individual products deserved dedicated caretakers. These “brand men,” as he called them, would shepherd a product through its entire journey, from conception to consumer hands. McElroy envisioned these managers as multifaceted leaders, accountable for the performance and direction of the product.

His innovative approach advocated for an intimate understanding of the market’s pulse, a strategic vantage point to anticipate and adapt to the evolving needs of customers, and a collaborative spirit to unite various functions within the company. He saw the potential in empowering managers to serve as the nexus of product information, direction, and improvement.

McElroy’s memo set into motion the wheels of a dedicated discipline. It is because of his foresight that today, Product Managers wield tools like competitive analysis, customer feedback loops, and cross-functional leadership. We are more than just overseers; we are the architects of our products’ destinies.

Looking back on nearly a century of product management evolution, I feel a profound respect for McElroy’s legacy. His framework laid the groundwork for a role that is indispensable in today’s business landscape. The fundamental principles he outlined endure, even as we adapt to the ever-changing tides of technology and consumer behavior.

In my day-to-day role, I endeavor to honor McElroy’s vision by balancing strategic oversight with a hands-on approach to problem-solving and innovation. As we continue to navigate the complexities of modern markets, it is more important than ever to adhere to the tenets laid out in that 1931 memo. By doing so, we pay homage to the roots of our profession and ensure that the spirit of product management remains as dynamic and relevant as it was at its inception.

--

--

Nikhil Chakravarthi

Product Management • Engineer • UI/UX Designer • Writer • Life Hacker